Speaking truth to power is an art, but increasingly a lost art. This goes as much for academia as for the rest of the world. Indeed and unfortunately, much of academia reflects the world in which it functions and often makes the challenge of deepening social justice harder rather than smaller. To put it bluntly, much of academia has resorted to instrumental and naïve beliefs in innovation, technology and efficiency (which dominate the natural sciences) or (as in much of the social-economic sciences) increasingly arcane niche debates that too often revolve around virtue-signalling, methodological-theoretical wizardry or apolitical pragmatism. What we seem to have lost to a good degree – though to be sure: it was never a dominant endeavour and at the same time it has never been absent either – is the art of speaking truth to power.
Land is power. Throughout most of history, the basis of power has been the control of labor. But when people have access to land, when people can gather, harvest or produce what they need, they will never accept to become laborers and obey a landlord or the boss of a factory. A key change in recent times is that the control of labor is no longer at the center of what makes power, because with mechanization, robotization, and biotechnology it's possible to work 10,000 hectares with very few people. What now allows the control over people is food, and it is also very much related to land.
I would like to make an argument that in aiming to deepen social justice in green transformations, we should pay renewed attention to the institutions of collective action at a very local level. I'm talking about peasant associations, irrigation groups, women's groups, indigenous people’s groups, producer associations, the local committees that manage land, water, forests.
Sous la houlette de la série Dialogues sur le foncier, le premier webinaire de la série de cette année "Genre et biodiversité : comment les femmes autochtones et des communautés locales sauvegardent la nature" s'est déroulé le 13 juin 2024. Le webinaire a attiré un peu plus de 300 participants et a mis en vedette des leaders autochtones et des communautés locales du monde entier. La série est organisée par un consortium d'organisations, dont la Fondation Land Portal, la Fondation Ford et la Tenure Facility, et ce webinaire particulier a été organisé en collaboration avec le GATC.
En el marco de la serie Diálogos sobre la Tierra, el 13 de junio de 2024 tuvo lugar el primer seminario web de la serie de este año "Género y biodiversidad: cómo las mujeres indígenas y de las comunidades locales salvaguardan la naturaleza". El seminario reunió a algo más de 300 participantes y contó con la participación de líderes indígenas y de comunidades locales de todo el mundo. La serie está organizada por un consorcio de organizaciones, entre ellas la Fundación Land Portal, la Fundación Ford y el Tenure Facility, y este seminario web en concreto se organizó en colaboración con el GATC.
Sob a coordenação da série Diálogos da Terra, o primeiro webinário da série deste ano, "Gênero e biodiversidade: como as mulheres indígenas e de comunidades locais protegem a natureza", foi realizado em 13 de junho de 2024. O webinário atraiu um pouco mais de 300 participantes e contou com a participação de líderes indígenas e de comunidades locais de todo o mundo. A série é organizada por um consórcio de organizações, incluindo a Fundação Land Portal, a Fundação Ford e o Tenure Facility, e esse webinário específico foi organizado em colaboração com o GATC.
Under the umbrella of the Land Dialogues series, the first webinar of this year’s series “Gender and Biodiversity : How Indigenous and Local Community Women Safeguard Nature” took place on June 13th, 2024. The webinar drew in a little over 300 participants and featured Indigenous and local community leaders from around the world. The series is organized by a consortium of organizations, including the Land Portal Foundation, the Ford Foundation and the Tenure Facility and this particular webinar was organized in collaboration with the GATC.
Nous vous demandons souvent de nous faire part de vos réactions. Sachant que cela demande du temps, des efforts et de la réflexion, nous vous sommes reconnaissants d'être si nombreux à le faire. Nous voulons que vous sachiez que nous lisons et écoutons les commentaires de chaque personne. Nous mettons en œuvre une boucle de rétroaction assez dynamique, mais au cas où vous vous demanderiez comment le Land Portal utilise les données et les commentaires des utilisateurs pour faire une réelle différence, voici un aperçu complet de notre système de suivi et d'évaluation (S&E) rigoureux et participatif. Ce blog est extrait de notre rapport annuel de S&E 2023, qui plonge en profondeur dans la façon dont nous collectons et analysons les données et les commentaires des utilisateurs afin de mener des initiatives percutantes pour une meilleure gouvernance foncière.
A menudo les pedimos su opinión. Sabiendo que esto lleva tiempo, esfuerzo y reflexión, estamos agradecidos de que tantos de ustedes lo hagan. Queremos que sepan que leemos y escuchamos los comentarios de cada persona. Llevamos a cabo un circuito de retroalimentación bastante dinámico, pero por si acaso se ha preguntado cómo Land Portal utiliza los datos y la retroalimentación de los usuarios para marcar una diferencia real, aquí tiene una visión completa de nuestro riguroso y participativo sistema de seguimiento y evaluación (M&E). Este blog está extraído de nuestro Informe Anual de Seguimiento y Evaluación 2023, que profundiza en cómo recopilamos y analizamos los datos y las opiniones de los usuarios para impulsar iniciativas de impacto que mejoren la gobernanza de la tierra.
Sempre pedimos seu feedback. Sabendo que isso exige tempo, esforço e reflexão, agradecemos o fato de muitos(as) de vocês fazerem isso. Queremos que você saiba que lemos e ouvimos os comentários de cada pessoa. Implementamos um ciclo de feedback bastante dinâmico, mas caso você tenha se perguntado como o Land Portal usa os dados e o feedback dos(as) usuários(as) para fazer uma diferença real, apresentamos aqui uma visão abrangente do nosso sistema rigoroso e participativo de monitoramento e avaliação (M&E). Este blog foi extraído do nosso Relatório Anual de M&A de 2023, que se aprofunda na forma como coletamos e analisamos os dados e o feedback dos(as) usuários(as) para promover iniciativas de impacto para uma melhor governança fundiária.
We often ask for feedback from you. Knowing this takes time, effort, and thought, we are grateful that so many of you do it. We want you to know that we read and hear every single person’s comments. We implement a fairly dynamic feedback loop, but just in case you have wondered how Land Portal uses data and users’ feedback to make a real difference, here is a comprehensive look at our rigorous and participatory monitoring and evaluation (M&E) system. This blog is taken from our 2023 Annual M&E Report, which dives deep into how we collect and analyze data and user feedback to drive impactful initiatives for better land governance.